Sell your house or keep it as a rental? Run both sets of numbers

If you are moving and wondering whether to sell or rent out your house, the answer is a comparison, not a hunch. Work out the cash a sale would put in your hands, then ask what the same house would earn on that cash as a rental once the tax bill, the insurance and the empty months change.

Quick answer, as of November 2026

Checked November 12, 2026: keep the house only if its yearly return on the cash a sale would free beats your other uses for that cash. In our hypothetical $330,000 home, selling frees about $123,100, and renting returns about 2.8 percent of that a year. IRS Publication 523 also limits the home sale exclusion to owners who lived there 24 months of the last five years.

Gregg Costin, Realtor, The Gregg Costin Team at Dalton Wade

By Gregg Costin, Realtor · Published · 10 minute read
Two-story house with cream siding, dark shutters, a two-car garage and a wide front lawn
A two-story house, shown for illustration and cropped from the original.

Key takeaways

You are moving, the mortgage on your current house has a rate you will never see again, and a neighbor says you would be crazy to sell. Maybe. A low payment is one input, and it is not the one that decides this.

Below, one hypothetical house is sold and rented on paper. Every price, rent and expense is an illustration that we made up for the arithmetic. None of it is market data, a rent estimate or advice for your tax return.

Should you sell your house or keep it as a rental?

Keep it only if the rental earns more on your equity than that cash would earn elsewhere. In our base example, a sale frees $123,100, and the rental returns $3,495 a year on it, or about 2.8 percent, most of it as loan paydown you cannot spend.

That framing matters because the choice is not really house against no house. It is $123,100 left inside one rental against $123,100 in your next down payment, your reserves or another investment. Rent that covers the mortgage tells you the house is not bleeding. It does not tell you the money is working.

How much cash would a sale actually free?

Less than the price, and the gap is the first number to pin down. Our owner bought six years ago for $250,000 and owes $183,800. At a $330,000 sale with 7 percent in hypothetical selling costs, or $23,100, the sale leaves $306,900, and paying off the loan leaves $123,100.

Your own figure depends on the payoff letter, the commission and concessions you negotiate, and closing charges. Our seller net proceeds guide lists each line, and the selling page explains how we price a home before it lists.

The gain here is $56,900, the $306,900 less the $250,000 paid. IRS Publication 523, the 2025 edition, says you may exclude the first $250,000 of gain from the sale of your home, and that the exclusion is increased to $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly. An owner who qualifies would owe no federal tax on this gain.

What does the same house earn as a rental?

In the base case it earns $10,746 before the mortgage and almost nothing after it. Rent of $2,100 with 5 percent vacancy collects $23,940, operating costs take $13,194, and the 3 percent loan's principal and interest take $10,751 a year. A $1,800 replacement reserve puts the year $1,805 in the red.

Those are the same operating lines as the house in our NOI and cash flow walkthrough. Two of them change the day you stop living there:

One hypothetical house kept as a rental: three annual cases against $123,100 of sale proceeds
Line (annual)ConservativeBaseUpside
Monthly rent and vacancy$2,000, 10%$2,100, 5%$2,250, 3%
Collected rent$21,600$23,940$26,190
Property tax, no homestead$4,800$4,800$4,800
Insurance$4,900$3,900$3,900
Management at 10%$2,160$2,394$2,619
Repairs$3,000$1,500$1,500
Yard, pest and miscellaneous$600$600$600
Net operating income$6,140$10,746$12,771
Mortgage principal and interest$10,751$10,751$10,751
Replacement reserve$1,800$1,800$1,800
Cash flowNegative $6,411Negative $1,805$220
Loan principal paid down$5,300$5,300$5,300
Total yearly returnNegative $1,111$3,495$5,520
Return on $123,100Negative 0.9%2.8%4.5%

The conservative year adds one more empty month, a storm-season insurance renewal and a $3,000 repair. None of that is unusual on the Gulf Coast. Appreciation is left out of every column, and so is the value of your own time.

How long can you rent it and still exclude the gain?

Up to about three years, if you lived there the two years before you left. Publication 523 asks whether you owned the home and used it as your residence for at least 24 months of the previous 5 years, and says the 24 months can fall anywhere within the 5-year period.

Renting after you move out does not, by itself, shrink the exclusion. The publication says a period of nonqualified use does not include any portion of the 5-year period ending on the date of the sale after the last date you used the property as your main home.

The clock is unforgiving at the far end. The sale has to close, not just list, while the 24 months still fall inside the five years. Miss the window and the whole $56,900 in our example becomes taxable gain. Mark the date before you sign a lease, and have a tax professional confirm it.

What tax comes due on depreciation when you sell later?

The part of the gain equal to your depreciation is taxed even when the exclusion applies. Publication 523 says you can't exclude the part of your gain equal to any depreciation allowed or allowable as a deduction for periods after May 6, 1997. Allowable means it counts whether or not you claimed it.

IRS Publication 527 sets the starting point. When you rent your former home, the basis for depreciation will be the lesser of the FMV or adjusted basis on the date of conversion. Land is not depreciated, and the publication's table gives residential rental property a recovery period of 27.5 years.

Here that basis is the $250,000 paid, not today's $330,000. Take out a hypothetical $50,000 for land and $200,000 is depreciated at about $7,273 a year, or about $21,818 over three full years. IRS Topic No. 409 taxes unrecaptured section 1250 gain at a maximum 25 percent rate, so that is up to about $5,455.

Set that against the return in the table. Three base-case years return $10,485 in total, and up to $5,455 of tax waits at the sale. This is an illustration that ignores the first-year partial month and your own bracket; it is not tax advice.

What happens to your Florida homestead when you rent?

Renting is treated as giving it up. Section 196.061 says the rental of all or substantially all of a dwelling previously claimed to be a homestead for tax purposes shall constitute the abandonment of such dwelling as a homestead. It adds that abandonment after January 1 does not affect that year's exemption unless the property is rented for more than 30 days per calendar year for 2 consecutive years.

Losing the exemption is the smaller change. Section 193.1554 has nonhomestead residential property assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year it becomes eligible, for levies other than school district levies. After that, a yearly change may not exceed 10 percent of the prior year's assessed value.

So a long-time owner's capped assessment can jump toward market value. Our property tax guide follows Amendment 3, the 2026 ballot measure that addresses that limit, and the homestead exemption guide covers filing.

You are expected to report the change. Section 196.011 requires an owner to notify the property appraiser promptly when the use of the property changes its exempt status. An owner who does not is subject to the taxes exempted plus 15 percent interest per annum and a penalty of 50 percent of the taxes exempted, for any year within the prior 10 years.

County offices look for it. The Santa Rosa County Property Appraiser lists renting homesteaded property among the reasons a parcel becomes ineligible. Whether your house is in Pace, Milton or Pensacola, call the appraiser's office in that county before the lease starts and ask what the next bill will be based on.

Does Alabama treat a rented house differently?

Yes, through the assessment class. The Alabama Department of Revenue places single-family owner occupied residential property in Class III, assessed at 10 percent of appraised value. Class II, all property not otherwise classified, is assessed at 20 percent.

Once the owner moves out, the house no longer fits the owner occupied description. On those percentages, a Baldwin County house appraised at $300,000 moves from $30,000 of assessed value to $60,000 before any millage is applied. The appraisal is hypothetical; the doubling is the point.

The exemption follows the same test. The department's homestead page defines a homestead as a single-family owner-occupied dwelling and the land thereto, not exceeding 160 acres. For a house in Foley, Gulf Shores or Orange Beach, ask the Baldwin County Revenue Commission how and when to report the change. Our Gulf Shores and Orange Beach page covers buying there.

Will the rent count when you buy your next home?

Partly, and the lender will not take your lease as proof. Fannie Mae's departing residence topic, dated September 2, 2026, has the lender multiply the monthly gross rent by 75 percent and subtract the old home's full payment. Lease agreements are not permitted; the rent comes from an appraiser's market rent report or a market analysis.

On our house, 75 percent of $2,100 is $1,575. The old home's payment with taxes and insurance is about $1,621 a month, so the rental counts as a shortfall of about $46 against your income, not as extra income.

The same topic requires six months of reserves for the old home's payment when the borrower has less than 12 months of property management experience. Here that is about $9,725 the lender wants to see, on top of the down payment you no longer have from a sale. Also read the occupancy section of your current mortgage. Other loan types have their own rules, so ask before you write an offer.

What would change our answer?

Several things, and each is specific to you. A documented rent well above $2,250 changes it. So does a house you intend to move back into, since you are then paying to hold a home, not an investment. A lender who needs neither the sale proceeds nor the rent to approve your next loan removes the pressure.

Taxes can help at the margin. Publication 527 says that with active participation you may be able to deduct up to $25,000 of loss from the activity from your nonpassive income, and that there is generally no special allowance once your MAGI is $150,000 or more. A deductible loss is still a loss.

The reverse is also true. If the conservative column looks like your likely year, or if you would be managing the house from another state with thin reserves, the sale is the safer plan even with a 3 percent loan.

What should you gather before you decide?

  1. A written payoff figure from your servicer and a net proceeds estimate at a realistic price.
  2. A rent estimate from current comparable leases, not from listings that have not rented.
  3. Your purchase closing statement and receipts for improvements, to establish basis.
  4. The dates you lived in the house, and the last day your sale could close inside the five-year window.
  5. A landlord insurance quote and the property appraiser's answer on next year's assessed value.
  6. Your association's leasing rules, including any cap on rentals or minimum lease term.
  7. Your next lender's written answer on the rent, the reserves and your current loan's occupancy terms.
  8. A cash reserve that covers a vacant month, a deductible and one major repair.

If you are also weighing furnished stays, our mid-term versus annual lease comparison uses this same rent. To test a payment on the next house, use the mortgage calculators. When you have the payoff and a rent estimate, send us the details and we will build the sale and the rental side by side with you.

Sources

Sources checked November 12, 2026. The price, loan, rent, costs and land value are hypothetical; they are not an appraisal, a rent estimate, legal advice or tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

How long can I rent out my house and still use the home sale exclusion?

IRS Publication 523 requires that you owned the home and used it as your residence for at least 24 months of the five years before the sale. If you lived there the full two years before moving out, that leaves up to about three years to rent it and close a sale. Depreciation from the rental years is still taxed. Confirm your own dates with a tax professional before you sign a long lease.

Do I lose my Florida homestead exemption as soon as a tenant moves in?

Section 196.061 says renting all or substantially all of a homestead is abandonment of it. The same section says abandonment after January 1 does not affect that year's exemption unless the property is rented more than 30 days per calendar year for two consecutive years. How that applies to your dates is a question for your county property appraiser, and you are required to tell that office when the use changes.

Can I use the rent to qualify for my next mortgage?

Often only part of it, and not with a lease alone. Fannie Mae's departing residence topic has the lender multiply market rent by 75 percent and subtract the old home's full payment. It does not permit a lease agreement as the documentation, and it requires six months of reserves when you have less than 12 months of property management experience. Other loan programs differ, so ask your lender first.

Can I deduct a loss if the rental costs more than it earns?

Possibly, within limits. IRS Publication 527 says that if you actively participated in a rental real estate activity, you may be able to deduct up to $25,000 of loss against other income. It also says there is generally no special allowance once modified adjusted gross income reaches $150,000. A loss you can deduct is still cash you spent, so treat this as a tax question for a professional, not a reason to keep the house.

Does a low mortgage rate mean I should keep the house?

It helps, but it does not settle the question. Our hypothetical loan is fixed at 3 percent, and the base case still only breaks even before reserves. The low rate lowers the payment; it does not raise the rent or lower the insurance. Compare the rental's return with what the freed cash would do in your next purchase, where it may reduce a loan at a much higher rate.

Should I count on appreciation when I compare the two?

We leave it out on purpose. Prices can rise, stay flat or fall while you own the rental, and a plan that only works if the house gains value is a bet on the market. If you want to include it, add it as a separate line with a flat case and a falling case beside it, and keep the cash flow honest on its own.

What if I plan to move back into the house later?

Then the comparison changes, because you are paying to hold a home you want, not just an investment. Florida's statute says the abandonment of a rented homestead continues until the dwelling is physically occupied by the owner. Ask your property appraiser how to reapply and how the assessed value will be set when you return, and ask your insurance agent how the policy converts back.

Put this guide to work

Send your payoff figure, a rent estimate and your moving date, and we will build the sale and the rental side by side with you.

Ask Gregg about your property plans

Permanent link

← Back to all posts

Call Text Email

Find what you need

Search our guides, neighborhoods, schools and real estate articles.

Loading search...

Browse the resource library or search homes for sale.